Skip to main content
Brand cover

Plymouth Cheese wholesale products

Find products for your store from thousands of brands.

About Plymouth Cheese

America's Oldest Cheddar. The factory still occupies the original building built in 1890 by Colonel John Coolidge, a dairy farmer and father to Calvin Coolidge, the 30th President of the United States. John Coolidge was looking to turn extra milk into a product with a longer shelf life. After generations in the Coolidge family, cheesemaker Jesse Werner took over the business in 2009, fulfilling a lifelong dream. Jesse had attended the Vermont Institute of Artisanal Cheese (VIAC) at the University of Vermont where he studied the craft including chemistry, microbiology, cultures and artisanal cheese design. He took on the momentous task of reviving the Plymouth Cheese Factory, the original cheese recipe, and the way the cheese was dipped in wax — the way it was done over 135 years ago on the Plymouth homestead. Jesse runs the business with the support of his brilliant wife, Sarit, who is responsible for designing the brand, packaging and marketing. His dynamic and charming parents bring the cheese to the people and support backend operations. And together with their team members, they’re keeping the Plymouth tradition alive. Today, Plymouth is the closest cheese you can find to the cheddar blocks that graced the kitchen tables of America’s first farmers.

TRUSTED BY HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF RETAILERS

More brands like Plymouth Cheese

Shop all
Cheese Brothers

Cheese Brothers was founded by two guys from Wisconsin with a mission to share great cheese with the world. They ship high quality, natural, and delicious Wisconsin cheeses nationwide, packaging them up with a bit of fun and whimsy. All of their cheeses are hand made in northern Wisconsin using only the finest local milk and natural ingredients. They put that same care into their packaging, with vibrant colors and engaging imagery that stands out on any retail shelf. Cheese Brothers ships to businesses large and small anywhere in the USA.

Birdie's Pimento Cheese

Birdie’s Pimento Cheese is a woman-owned brand offering a curious twist on snacking tradition. We are a high end product but still relatable. As a specialty pimento cheese, Birdie’s is a craft, whole food that easily pairs with wine, beer, and whiskey, and is at home on a charcuterie board. Our many flavors offer something for all tastes, and fans are known to create unexpected recipes incorporating Birdie’s. Offering year round and seasonal flavors, we easily peak the interest of the most discerning foodie consumer.

Keystone Farms Cheese

All of our cheeses are made in small batches with the finest ingredients possible. The ingredients are simple and honest – No additives. No preservatives. No rBST. No gluten. Keystone Farms Cheese was established in 2014 after owner, Nikole, spent years traveling back and forth from Pennsylvania to Wisconsin visiting her father and grandmother. Bringing back cheese for family and friends, she soon realized the taste, quality and unique flavors found in Wisconsin cheese were not available back home in Bethlehem, PA.   Starting in a small one room office with a one car garage, Keystone Farms Cheese now distributes over 4 tons of cheese per year, nationwide to restaurants, wineries, small businesses and local craft & wine festivals in Eastern PA, NJ and upstate NY.  Female founded and enthusiastically led, Keystone Farms originally started as a one women show and has since expanded to a small team of captivating, extra cheesy ladies!  At Keystone Farms Cheese, we believe in real cheese with no B.S. ingredients. Working directly with small family factories and farms throughout Wisconsin we source the highest quality, handcrafted products for our cheese loving fans. 

Smith's Country Cheese

Smith's Country Cheese is a working family dairy farm, crafting our famous Gouda, Cheddar, and Havarti cheeses with the milk from our own herd. We use traditional recipes and raw milk to create an unparalleled depth of flavor. We lab-test every single batch before we sell it to ensure safety. When you order from us, you're not only getting top-quality farmstead cheese, you're supporting a small family farm too!

Northwoods Food and Gift Enterprises

We are a Gourmet Food Distributor. We supply shelf stable Cheese and Sausage and other Gourmet Food and Gifts to the Gift Industry. Our specialty Food and best Seller is our Cranberry Cheddar shelf stable cheese and also our All Beef Cranberry Sausage. We also sell Wholesale Gourmet Gifts for businesses to utilize all year round and especially during the Holidays. We have been in business for 20 years and have become a husband/wife team 3 years ago. We utilize businesses that hire persons with disabilities whenever we can to help them give back to the community and achieve dignity through work. Right now with our wood creations and engraving.

Ready to start buying wholesale online?

60-day payment terms

Free returns on all opening orders

Unique products curated for your store